PanamaTimes

Saturday, Sep 07, 2024

DA in Trump Org closings accuses Donald Trump of 'sanctioning tax fraud' — and implies 1 witness was paid off

DA in Trump Org closings accuses Donald Trump of 'sanctioning tax fraud' — and implies 1 witness was paid off

A Trump Org. prosecutor said his own star-witness was encouraged to "shade the truth" by his big Trump salary and potential for a $500,000 bonus.

A Manhattan prosecutor went to extraordinary lengths during closing arguments in the Trump Organization tax-fraud trial on Friday, accusing Donald Trump of personally "sanctioning tax fraud" and suggesting his side's own star witness had financial incentive — a potential $500,000 company bonus — to "shade the truth."

"Mr. Trump is explicitly sanctioning tax fraud — that's what this document shows," Joshua Steinglass, one of two lead prosecutors, told jurors, going further in fiery closing arguments than the district attorney's office has ever publically gone toward implicating the former president in a crime.

Steinglass was pointing to a 2012 internal company memo projected onto large screens in the courtroom.


This 2012 memo shows Donald Trump 'explicitly sanctioning tax fraud,' a prosecutor said in closing arguments on December 2, 2022, in the Trump Organization tax-fraud trial.

In the now decade-old memo, Trump signed his first initial, "D," and the word "OK" to approve an "Annual Salary Deduction" of $72,000 for the company's chief operating officer, Matthew Calamari.

Read the entire memo here.

Trump's "OK" shows he was well aware, the prosecutor argued, of the tax-dodge scheme at the center of the six-week trial.

Masterminded by ex-CFO Allen Weisselberg, the 2005-2018 scheme let Trump's top-tier executives take chunks of their pay in the form of tax-free perks, including cars and apartments. The value of these perks would often then be subtracted from the executives' actual W-2 forms — in Calamari's case, a subtraction of $72,000.

The defense, meanwhile, has insisted the Trump Organization should not be liable for the scheme, which they say started and stopped with Weisselberg.

The defense has also argued that although Trump signed off on the cars, apartments, bonuses, and other elements of the scheme, he was utterly in the dark about whether his executives were cheating on their taxes.

"Objection!" multiple defense lawyers shouted when the prosecutor accused Trump of "sanctioning tax fraud," interrupting the closing arguments.  

"Sustained," said the trial's presiding judge, New York Supreme Court Justice Juan Merchan, sounding somewhat exasperated.

The two sides have tangled for days with increasing vitriol; the prosecution's "sanctioning tax fraud" claim would be one in a litany of reasons, all rejected by the judge, behind a defense demand for a mistrial.

"That's what this document shows," Steinglass protested.

"Counsel, approach," the judge responded.

"I just want to caution you, Mr. Steinglass, not to go too far," the judge said during a several-minute sidebar, outside jurors' earshot.

"This is as far as I'm going," Steinglass answered.

"Remind them again that none of this is offered to in any way put Donald Trump on trial," the judge warned. "He's not on trial."

Trump Org. lawyer Susan Necheles then began arguing with Steinglass over who had interrupted whose summations more often. 

"Stop it, Josh," she said. "Come on. Given how much you interrupted me? Judge, we go back to the issue that he just argued Donald Trump was explicitly authorizing tax fraud," she complained.

The prosecutor continued his summations, avoiding further accusations of Trumpian fraud-sanctioning, but insisting again, "this whole narrative that Donald Trump is blissfully ignorant is just not real."

A spokeswoman for the Manhattan DA's office declined to comment when asked why Trump was never charged in the scheme.

Accusing Weisselberg, his own witness, of "shading the truth" on the stand was even more crucial to Steinglass' summations strategy.

New York law requires proof that executives intended to benefit their company, not just themselves. Otherwise, a company cannot be held liable for its executives' wrongdoing.

But Weisselberg repeatedly told jurors during three days on the stand in mid-November that his only intention in masterminding the scheme was to help himself. That left Steinglass on Friday to imply Weisselberg, a less-than-ideal prosecution witness, lied to protect his company and his bottom line.

Weisselberg "has half a million reasons to shade the truth to their side," Steinglass told jurors, a reference to the half-million-dollar Trump Organization bonus that the ex-CFO may or may not get in January, just weeks after the trial.

In the meantime, the former top money man who testified as part of a low-jail plea deal, must subsist on this year's $640,000 salary and $500,000 bonus, again courtesy of the Trump payroll. It's literally a no-show job; Weisselberg has been on paid leave since October.

Trump himself has never been criminally charged in connection with his real-estate and golf-resort empire, though he has been accused of a longstanding pattern of fraud as part of a $250 million civil lawsuit filed by New York's attorney general, Letitia James.

The Manhattan case charges two corporate subsidiaries — the Trump Corporation and the Trump Payroll Corporation, both doing business as the Trump Organization — with scheme to defraud, conspiracy and related tax-fraud crimes.

Jury deliberations are set to begin Monday morning. The subsidiaries face up to $1.6 million in penalties, along with the black eye of felony status, if convicted.

Newsletter

Related Articles

PanamaTimes
0:00
0:00
Close
BRAZIL’S SUPREME COURT MINISTER ORDERS EXPLANATION ON X BLOCKING
Porn streamer OnlyFans paid owner $630mn in dividends
Donald Trump will not face sentencing over his 'hush money' conviction before the US presidential election on November 5, after a Manhattan judge granted his request to delay the proceeding
Return of Brazilian Artworks to Bahia
France Pilots Mobile Phone Ban in Schools
WHO-Led Study Finds No Link Between Mobile Phones and Brain Cancer
Kamala Harris is in Detroit and has a new accent again
EU Rejects Maduro’s Election Win Claim in Venezuela
Former Red Brigades Member Arrested in Argentina After 40 Years on Run
Elon Musk Accuses Brazilian Supreme Court Justice of Election Interference
Universe May Have Had a Pre-Big Bang 'Secret Life'
Ecuador's Narco Violence Threatens Scientists and Conservation Efforts
Brazilian Judge Alexandre de Moraes Blocks Elon Musk's X
Nаkеd American woman gropes security
Tsimane Tribe: Secrets to Health and Slow Ageing
OpenAI Blocks Iranian Group's ChatGPT Accounts for Election Interference
WHO Declares Mpox Global Health Emergency Again
Decline in World Records at Paris Olympics: An Analysis
EU Pressures Elon Musk Over Trump Interview
UN Reports Lowest Global Youth Unemployment Rate in 15 Years
Fatal Plane Crash Near Sao Paulo
Snoop Dogg: The Feel-Good Spirit of the Paris Olympics
McDonald's Worker Sets Restaurant On Fire Over Customer Frustration
Kamala Harris Confirmed as Democratic Candidate for US Presidential Election
Controversies at the Paris Olympics
Elon Musk Accepts Fight Challenge from Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro
First Case of 'Virgin Birth' in Endangered Shark Species in Italy
G20 Fails to Reach Agreement on Global Billionaire Tax
Mexican Drug Lords El Mayo and El Chapo's Son Arrested in Texas
World's Hottest Day Recorded on July 21
Joe Biden Withdraws from 2024 US Presidential Race
A Week of Turmoil: Key Moments in US Politics
Global IT Outage Sparks Major Concerns
Global IT Outage Unveils Digital Vulnerabilities
Secret Service Criticized for Lack of Sniper Protection During Trump Shooting
Colombian Court Annuls Amazon Tribes’ Carbon Credit Deal
Sunita Williams Safe on ISS, to Address Earth on July 10
Biden Affirms Commitment To Presidential Race
Boeing Pleads Guilty Over 737 MAX Crashes
Beryl Storm Hits Texas, Killing 2 and Causing Major Power Outages
2024 Predicted to Be World's Hottest Year
Macron Faces New Political Challenges Despite Election Relief
Florida Man Arrested Over Attempt to Withdraw One Cent
Anger mounts at Biden’s top team after disastrous debate
Bolivian President Luis Arce Denies 'Self-Coup' Allegations
Steve Bannon Begins 4-Month Prison Sentence
Biden Warns of 'Dangerous Precedent' After Supreme Court Immunity Ruling in Trump Case
Elon Musk Accuses Kamala Harris of Misleading Post on Trump's Abortion Stance
Hunter Biden Sues Fox News Over 'Revenge Porn' Allegations
New York Times Editorial Board Urges Biden to Exit Presidential Race
×