PanamaTimes

Saturday, Dec 07, 2024

Exclusive: Mexican officials at oil regulator who rejected Pemex plans were pressured to quit - sources

Exclusive: Mexican officials at oil regulator who rejected Pemex plans were pressured to quit - sources

Last June, Mexico's oil regulator unanimously rejected a plan presented by state energy company Pemex to develop its biggest discovery in three decades, arguing the proposal was both economically and technically unsound.

Five months later, on Nov. 24, the regulator approved the plan for the Quesqui field in the southern state of Tabasco.

In the intervening period, the government of President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador replaced the head of the National Hydrocarbons Commission (CNH), Rogelio Hernandez, with a former Pemex (PEMX.UL) official, Agustin Diaz Lastra.

Interviews with eight sources with direct knowledge of the matter show Hernandez had been pressured by Lopez Obrador's government and Pemex to approve Quesqui and other plans, or resign.

Reuters also reviewed six public and four internal documents related to the plans to understand how they were approved and what the concerns were.

The individuals interviewed for this story spoke to Reuters on the condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to speak publicly about an issue the government had declared a matter of national security.

According to these people, at least three other senior officials at the regulator were also pressured by officials in government and at the regulator to help approve the plans.

Several audio files - recorded after Hernandez left - confirm this. Reuters was allowed to listen to the files on condition that details that could identify the source would not be revealed.

Pemex, the energy ministry and the government did not respond to repeated requests for comment.

One of the officials who the sources said was pressured, the former technical head, Julio Trejo, resigned shortly before the Quesqui plan was approved.

Three out of four voting senior officials at the regulator voted in favor of greenlighting Pemex's plan in November, including the new head of the regulator.

Hector Moreira, one of the four, responded to Reuters with a brief statement issued through the regulator saying the plan for Quesqui was found viable the second time and was supported by studies - without explaining which elements had changed. The regulator declined to comment further.

In public and internal documents related to the plans and Pemex's management of Quesqui, the former head of the regulator, Hernandez, and former technical head, Trejo, had strongly opposed the development plan for the field, arguing it was not sufficiently tried and tested, and too expensive.

In August, Hernandez resigned under pressure from government officials, the eight sources said. He was replaced in October by Diaz Lastra, one of three candidates presented by Lopez Obrador for a vote by the Senate, which his party controls.

One source at the energy ministry, who attended meetings where disagreements between Pemex and the regulator over several key fields were discussed, said Hernandez and Trejo were considered "obstacles" by Pemex in plans to boost production.

In November, Trejo also quit the regulator and was replaced - a week before the second vote on Nov. 24 - by Rafael Guerrero, whose previous job was Pemex's legal representative responsible for dealing with the regulator.

In one previously unreported document dated July 29, Guerrero stressed the importance of Quesqui for production and urged the regulator to approve the plan.

On Pemex letterhead, he wrote that federal and other entities like the regulator "are instructed to carry out the actions, as indicated by the Mexican government, for projects and works that are of public interest and national security."

Guerrero also reiterated that the Quesqui field "is a strategic project" as defined by the government.

In mid-November, Guerrero was appointed by Diaz Lastra and put in charge of the technical unit for extraction and supervision – a key role in which he made a recommendation to the four officials who voted on the plan.

Around a week later the plan was approved with the votes of three of the four senior officials - the new president, Diaz Lastra, as well as Moreira and Nestor Martinez, both of whom had previously rejected the plan.

Guerrero had advised them to vote in favor, according to a public document in which the technical head issues his recommendation for senior officials with voting rights.

Neither Guerrero nor Diaz Lastra responded to repeated requests for comment.

Moreira's April 13 statement to Reuters, issued by the regulator, said the panel had "found the plan technically, economically and legally viable supported by studies" Pemex presented. Martinez declined to comment for this article.

Alma America Porres, who stuck with her vote against, left the regulator in January at the previously scheduled end of her term.


PLANS UNCHANGED


More than a dozen energy experts told Reuters the changes at the regulator weaken one of the last remaining independent bodies with oversight of Pemex, a massive near-monopoly that is also the top contributor to state coffers.

Reuters did not have access to the plans for Quesqui, which are protected in Mexico as state secrets.

But five of the sources - who have seen both versions of the plan - said the iteration approved in November was almost identical to the one that had been rejected in June.

There were only minor changes, such as adjustments for inflation and to make up for lapsed time after the plan was stalled, they said.

In rejecting the plan in June, the regulator cited issues such as a lack of comprehensive studies and trials for a strategy that sees Pemex inject water into the field, three public and two internal documents reviewed by Reuters show.

In one internal document dated Aug. 5, the regulator argued that the plan to inject water into Quesqui was "poorly analyzed", "without basis" and risked "irreparable damage" to the country's most valuable field.

Those issues were not addressed in the later version, the five sources told Reuters.

In both, the overall budget was just over $3 billion.

Lopez Obrador has been pushing Pemex to reverse a nearly-two-decade production decline. Quesqui, with Mexico's largest gas reserves and third-largest condensate reserves, is a vital part of that strategy.

The sources told Reuters that proceeding with the plan could indeed boost short-term production but all agreed with the regulator's initial assessment in June that it would almost certainly reduce the overall amount that can be produced.

It would likely damage the field, the sources said, because injecting water into the field was not a strategy compatible with the geological formation of Quesqui.

Newsletter

Related Articles

PanamaTimes
0:00
0:00
Close
Special counsel Jack Smith asks the court to dismiss his appeal against Trump in the Mar-a-Lago classified documents case.
A Chinese retail chain has substituted traditional mannequins with real women walking on treadmills to display their clothes in motion.
Iranian Man Charged in Plot to Assassinate Donald Trump
Vatican Synod Concludes with Support for Women in Leadership Roles
Biden Labels Trump a Threat to Democracy
McDonald's Linked to E. coli Outbreak Leading to One Death
AI Regulation Takes Center Stage in 2024 US Presidential Campaign
Cuba's Power Struggles: Nationwide Blackout Strikes Again
Meta Faces Legal Battle Over Teen Social Media Addiction
UK Government Proposes Weight-Loss Injections to Combat Obesity and Boost Employment
Russia's Call for a BRICS Financial System Alternative
Indigenous Groups in Brazil Protest Carbon Credit Deal
Tesla's Robotaxi Design Strikes Controversy
Boeing to Reduce Workforce by 10% Amid Financial Strain
Brazilian Man Arrested for Decades-long Abuse and Imprisonment of Family
Donald Trump Amplifies Anti-Migrant Sentiments in Colorado Speech
Mass Looting of Chicago Cargo Train: 50 to 150 Looters Ransack Containers in Chaotic Scene
The Impact of Online Culture on Young Women: Survey Insights
Hypersonic Jet to Revolutionize Air Travel
Facilitated Communication: Miracle Tool or Manipulative Method?
US Election 2024: A Deadlock Between Trump and Harris
Dominica Sells Citizenship to Boost Climate Resilience
Elon Musk's X Faces Fines and Account Error in Brazil
Scott Jennings leaves CNN panel speechless as he tears apart Tim Walz's flimsy excuse of being "too dumb to tell the truth."
Earth Faces Severe Geomagnetic Storm from Solar Flare
China-Led Bloc Challenges The Quad in Indo-Pacific Region
Biden-Harris sent forklifts to open the border when Texas built a razor wall.
Storm Helene Devastates Eastern and Midwestern US, Claims 44 Lives
Trump Taps Elon Musk to Lead Federal Spending Cuts, Promising Trillions in Savings
Importing voters: With an election looming, the U.S. is approving citizenship applications at the fastest speed in years.
Hurricane Helene Set to Slam Florida with 'Unsurvivable' Conditions
El Salvadoran President Bukele at the UN: "Some complain that we put thousands in prison. In reality, we set millions free."
Google Commits 120 Million Dollars for Global AI Education: Sundar Pichai
Tennessee Woman Sentenced for Attempted Murder-For-Hire
Amazon Rainforest Suffers Massive Deforestation
Earth's Planetary Boundaries Breached
Elon Musk’s X Circumvents Brazil’s Supreme Court Block
Brazilian Judge Accuses Elon Musk’s X of Circumventing Court-Ordered Ban
Venezuelan Opposition Leader Coerced into Recognizing Maduro's Victory
Brazil's Firefighters Battle Amazon Blazes and Arsonists
X Social Media Platform Ordered Offline Again in Brazil
Global Workdays Required to Afford iPhone 16
In his podcast, Joe Rogan rightly questioned, "YOU NEED A VACCINE PASSPORT FOR FOOD, BUT VOTER ID IS ‘RACIST'?!"
Trump Unveils New Cryptocurrency Venture Amidst Campaign
X Update Enables App to Bypass Brazil Ban, Say Internet Providers
Delta Airlines Sets Strict Wardrobe Guidelines for Flight Attendants
Norway Achieves Milestone in Electric Vehicle Adoption
Hezbollah Hit by Explosive Pagers in Lebanon
Ex-Soldier Describes Trump Assassination Suspect's Troubled Ukraine Stint
Ghislaine Maxwell's Sex-Trafficking Conviction Upheld by Appeals Court
×